The Digestive Botanicals Atlas · botanicals.jimhasadhd.fyi/watch-out/buying/
Buying it
20 plants and preparations in the atlas carry a warning for this. Each one is here in full, most serious first, with who it's for in the researcher's own words.
Not on this list isn't the same as safe: it may just not have been studied. Why.
Avoid
Star anise Plant
AvoidJapanese star anise, a toxic relative, looks the same once dried and has turned up mixed into the spice. Its neurotoxin, anisatin, causes nausea, vomiting and seizures: in 2001 a contaminated herbal tea in the Netherlands made 63 people ill and put 22 in hospital, 16 of them with seizures. The EU put special import checks on star anise from 2002 until 2003, when they found no new contamination. Buy star anise as a food spice from a reputable supplier, and skip star anise teas and remedies of unknown origin. For: star anise teas and remedies of unknown origin.
Sources: US Food and Drug Administration 2003regulatorNederlands Tijdschrift voor Geneeskunde 2002case reportEuropean Commission 2002regulatorEuropean Commission 2003regulator
Yaojiu Preparation
AvoidAconite (fuzi, chuanwu, caowu) is traditional in some medicinal liquors, and it's the tradition's great danger. Its alkaloids dissolve readily in alcohol, so aconite liquors cause most aconite poisonings in China. Hong Kong's poison specialists list "herbal medicinal wine" among the main causes and urge people not to make their own. Never drink a liquor that might contain aconite unless a registered practitioner prescribed it. For: anyone making or buying unregistered medicinal liquors.
Sources: Human & Experimental Toxicology 2011narrative reviewForensic Science International 2012narrative reviewJournal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 2016case report
Take care
Costus Plant
CautionWatch the name. "Muxiang" has look-alike herbs: qingmuxiang, for example, is the root of an Aristolochia, and Aristolochia's aristolochic acids destroy kidneys and cause cancer. Costus root is one of the herbs that has been confused with Aristolochia material, so buy only from regulated suppliers that test identity. For: buyers of Chinese herbs.
Sources: Food Chemistry 2014lab or genetic studyPhytomedicine 2007narrative reviewUS Food and Drug Administration (CFSAN) 2000regulator
Sahlab Preparation
CautionTrue salep is dug from wild orchids, and the trade is pushing salep orchids into decline from Greece to Iran; every orchid species is under international trade control. A starch-based mix makes the same cosy cup without the digging. For: anyone buying salep.
Sources: Current Biology 2026lab or genetic studyEuropean Commission (EUR-Lex) 2023regulator
Good to know
Atractylodes Plant
NoteNo regulator we checked lists specific warnings for the rhizome itself. The risks are in the product: Hong Kong's official standard tests it for heavy metals, pesticide residues and mould toxins, so buy crude drugs and pills from a regulated supplier. For: buyers of crude drugs.
Sources: Department of Health, Hong Kong (Chinese…regulator
Boldo Plant
NoteNaming trap. In Brazil "boldo" (boldo-brasileiro, boldo-nacional, boldo-africano) often means Plectranthus barbatus, an unrelated mint-family plant with its own, longer list of warnings. Check the Latin name on the packet. For: shoppers in Brazil.
Sources: Agência Nacional de Vigilância Sanitária… 2026regulator
Chenpi tea Preparation
NoteAged chenpi is expensive and faked. In 2025 China's state broadcaster reported peel sold with false ages, origins and processing; a Xinhua commentary describes peel bought wholesale for 70 yuan and sold for 1,000. Older reports describe cheaper peel passed off as Xinhui and peel dyed with black tea to look old. Buy from a trusted seller. For: buyers of aged chenpi.
Sources: Xinhua (from The Beijing News) 2025press景盛庄 (King Shing Chong), chenpi merchantmaker
Korarima Plant
NoteBuy from a seller you trust. When Ethiopian chemists tested market spices in Fiche, the korarima, ginger, turmeric and red pepper samples all carried lead and cadmium above the WHO's limits. As a kitchen spice korarima is a food; nobody has studied it at medicinal doses, in pregnancy or alongside medicines. For: anyone buying loose spices.
Sources: Biological Trace Element Research 2024lab or genetic study
Kudzu Plant
NoteNo regulator we checked lists specific warnings for the root itself. The risks are in the product: Hong Kong's official standard tests it for heavy metals, pesticide residues and mould toxins, so buy from a regulated supplier. For: buyers of crude drugs.
Sources: Department of Health, Hong Kong (Chinese…regulator
Lahpet Preparation
NoteBuy from makers you trust. In 2009 Myanmar's Ministry of Health banned about 100 brands of lahpet after finding Auramine O, an industrial textile dye linked to liver and kidney disease, used to brighten the leaves. For: anyone buying lahpet.
Sources: Burma News International (reprinting Mizzima,… 2009press
Lemon verbena Plant
NoteNaming trap in Brazil: erva-cidreira (Lippia alba) and capim-cidreira (lemongrass, Cymbopogon citratus) are different plants from cedrón, even though the names sound alike. For: shoppers in Brazil.
Sources: Agência Nacional de Vigilância Sanitária… 2026regulator
Magnolia Bark Plant
NoteNo regulator we checked lists specific warnings for the bark itself. The risks are in the product: Hong Kong's official standard tests it for heavy metals, pesticide residues and mould toxins, so buy from a regulated supplier. For: buyers of crude drugs.
Sources: Department of Health, Hong Kong (Chinese…regulator
Mandarin peel Plant
NoteMandarin peel is an everyday food, and no regulator we checked lists specific warnings. The risks are in the product. Hong Kong's official standard tests chenpi for heavy metals, pesticide residues and mould toxins, and in 2025 China's state broadcaster exposed aged chenpi with faked ages and origins. Buy from a seller you trust. For: buyers of aged chenpi.
Sources: Department of Health, Hong Kong (Chinese…regulatorXinhua (from The Beijing News) 2025press
Mukhwas Preparation
NoteSome after-meal mixes sold alongside mukhwas, such as supari blends and paan, contain areca (betel) nut, which IARC classifies as carcinogenic to humans. The seed mukhwas recorded here contains none, but check the label of anything called supari or paan masala. For: anyone buying supari or paan style mixes.
Sources: International Agency for Research on Cancer… 2004referenceThe Takeout 2018press
Patchouli Plant
NoteNo regulator we checked lists specific warnings for the herb itself. The risks are in the product: Hong Kong's official standard tests it for heavy metals, pesticide residues, aflatoxins and sulphur dioxide, so buy crude drugs and pills from a regulated supplier. For: buyers of crude drugs.
Sources: Department of Health, Hong Kong (Chinese…regulator
Picrasma Plant
NoteNo regulator we checked lists specific warnings for picrasma itself. Hong Kong's official standard tests the crude drug for heavy metals, pesticide residues, mould toxins and sulphur dioxide, so buy from a regulated supplier, and as with other bitters, check with a doctor first if you have a stomach ulcer. For: buyers of crude drugs.
Sources: Department of Health, Hong Kong (Chinese…regulator
Po Chai Pills Preparation
NoteIn 2010 some Po Chai Pills capsules were found to contain two banned Western drugs, the laxative phenolphthalein and the weight-loss drug sibutramine, and all the maker's products were recalled. The bottled pills tested clean and returned in May 2010; the capsules were discontinued. Buy registered products (a Hong Kong registration number starts HKP-, HKC- or HKNT-) from a reputable pharmacy. For: buyers.
Sources: Department of Health, Hong Kong 2010regulatorDepartment of Health, Hong Kong 2010regulatorLi Chung Shing Tong (Holdings) Limitedmaker
Poria Plant
NoteNo regulator we checked lists specific warnings for poria itself. The risks are in the product: Hong Kong's official standard tests it for heavy metals, pesticide residues, aflatoxins and sulphur dioxide, so buy from a regulated supplier. For: buyers of crude drugs.
Sources: Department of Health, Hong Kong (Chinese…regulator
Saffron Plant
NoteSaffron is the world's priciest spice and is often faked or bulked out. In Morocco, food-safety inspectors found "non-conformities" in loose saffron sold in bulk; buy sealed, labelled threads, ideally with a protected origin. For: shoppers.
Sources: Mail & Guardian (AFP) 2018press
Slippery elm powder Preparation
NoteWild slippery elm is on United Plant Savers' At-Risk list of North American medicinal plants; look for cultivated or responsibly harvested bark. For: anyone buying slippery elm.
Sources: United Plant Saversweb