In January 1949 TIME counted 46 kinds of ulcer diet and 108 drugs that doctors had already tried, then added a new one: cabbage juice. Dr Garnett Cheney of Stanford's School of Medicine had been chasing an anti-ulcer factor he called "vitamin U", found plenty of it in cabbage, and gave 13 patients a quart of fresh raw juice a day, a glass at a time. Their ulcers healed in days rather than weeks, he reported, though he called it short of final proof. A larger series and a double-blind trial at San Quentin Prison followed. His "vitamin U" turned out to be S-methylmethionine, not a true vitamin.
The juice travelled. Soviet doctors used white cabbage juice, preserved and dehydrated, in ulcer diet therapy into the 1970s, and German pharmacies still sell bottled raw white-cabbage juice beside its fermented cousin, sauerkraut juice. Same plant, different vehicles: the crock gives you sauerkraut, the juicer gives you this. Then medicine changed underneath it: most ulcers turned out to be caused by H. pylori or anti-inflammatory painkillers, and no modern trial has retested the juice. Cabbage juice is a living folk remedy with an intriguing 1950s paper trail, not a replacement for ulcer treatment.
Sources: TIME 1949pressCalifornia Medicine 1949case report
What's in it
1 reported elsewhere.| Botanical | Part | Status | Sources |
|---|
| Cabbage Brassica oleracea var. capitata | leaf (fresh, raw, pressed) | ◐ Reported | Sources: TIME 1949press |
|---|
One ingredient. Cheney kept his patients' other food cooked, so the raw juice was their only source of his "vitamin U".
Sources: TIME 1949press
Watch out
- Caution Ulcer pain needs a diagnosis, not just a juicer. Most stomach ulcers come from H. pylori infection or long-term anti-inflammatory painkillers, and they're treated with antibiotics or acid-reducing medicines. Cabbage juice alongside that is a food choice, not a substitute. · peptic ulcer
Sources: MedlinePlus (US National Library of Medicine)reference
- Caution Raw cabbage is rich in vitamin K, and a litre of juice a day is a lot of raw cabbage. If you take warfarin, talk to your doctor before starting, and keep the amount steady once you do. · anticoagulants
Sources: MedlinePlus (US National Library of Medicine)reference
- Note Very high intakes of raw cabbage-family vegetables caused hypothyroidism in animals. In people this seems to matter mainly alongside iodine deficiency, but a daily litre of raw juice is well beyond a normal serve, so check with your doctor if you have a thyroid condition. · thyroid disease, iodine deficiency
Sources: Linus Pauling Institute Micronutrient…reference
And from the botanicals inside, as noted on their own pages. Amounts in a juice differ, but these are worth knowing:
Cabbage: CautionCabbage is rich in vitamin K. If you take warfarin, you don't need to avoid it, but keep the amount you eat steady from week to week, and talk to your doctor before starting a daily cabbage-juice habit. For: anticoagulants.2 more notes on its page
How it's taken
Cheney's patients drank about a quart (roughly a litre) of fresh raw juice a day, a glass at a time, five times a day. A German pharmacy juice today suggests one 200 ml glass a day before meals.
Sources: TIME 1949pressShop Apotheke (product listing for SALUS…retailer
Over the years
Cheney's concentrated cabbage juice (San Quentin trial)
United States · 1950s · historical
A concentrate of cabbage juice, tested against a look-alike placebo in a double-blind trial among inmates at San Quentin Prison, with ulcer craters checked by X-ray after 22 days.
Sources: California Medicine 1956trial
Schoenenberger Weißkohl Bio-Saft
Germany and Austria · current
Bottled pressed juice of fresh, unfermented organic white cabbage, sold in pharmacies by SALUS, with a suggested 200 ml glass a day before meals. The same maker sells a fermented sauerkraut juice (see the sauerkraut page).
Sources: Shop Apotheke (product listing for SALUS…retailer
The evidence
fresh raw cabbage juice, about a quart (roughly a litre) a day in five glasses
Cheney reported that peptic ulcers in 13 people healed in 7 to 10 days on average on fresh cabbage juice, against five or six weeks in published series on standard care, and a 1952 report on 100 patients said the same. Neither had its own control group, the work predates the discovery of H. pylori, and Cheney himself called it short of final proof.
Sources: California Medicine 1949case reportCalifornia Medicine 1952case reportTIME 1949press
SoreSome evidencevery low certainty · adults with peptic ulcer (San Quentin Prison) concentrated cabbage juice, against a look-alike placebo
Cheney's one controlled study, a double-blind trial at San Quentin Prison, judged ulcer craters by X-ray after 22 days and reported that the concentrate beat the placebo. It was small, has never been repeated, and ulcer care has since moved to antibiotics and acid-reducing medicines.
Sources: California Medicine 1956trial
And for cabbage itself
- Cabbage Some evidence for sore · concentrated cabbage juice, against a look-alike placebo